Judge postpones discovery in Kilmar Abrego Garcia case for reasons unknown amid tensions with Trump admin
By Ryan King,
21 days agoThe federal judge overseeing Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s lawsuit against the Trump administration abruptly decided Wednesday to impose a seven-day delay on discovery for reasons that aren’t immediately clear.
Following a sealed petition from Justice Department lawyers seeking a delay, presiding US District Judge Paula Xinis revealed in court filings that the two sides reached an agreement to postpone discovery. She did not elaborate on the decision.
Wednesday’s order marks a reversal from a day earlier, when Xinis had called for an expedited discovery and demanded that Trump administration officials testify about Abrego Garcia’s deportation
While the rationale for a potential delay is unclear, the petition comes after presiding US District Judge Paula Xinis ordered an expedited discovery and demanded that Trump administration officials testify about Abrego Garcia’s deportation.
“For weeks, Defendants have sought refuge behind vague and unsubstantiated assertions of privilege, using them as a shield to obstruct discovery and evade compliance with this Court’s orders,” Xinis wrote in a scathing order Tuesday .
“Defendants have known, at least since last week, that this Court requires specific legal and factual showings to support any claim of privilege. Yet they have continued to rely on boilerplate assertions. That ends now.”
She further chided them for exhibiting “a willful and bad faith refusal to comply with discovery obligations.”
DOJ attorneys had argued Tuesday that furnishing specific information about the legal justifications for Abrego Garcia’s detention would be “wholly inappropriate and an invasion of diplomatic discussions,” court filings show.
They argued that it is “no longer a matter of the United States’ confinement” but rather an issue for the government of El Salvador to consider.
Earlier this month, Xinis had ruled that the Trump administration must “facilitate” the return of Abrego Garcia to the US and has repeatedly rebuked DOJ lawyers for not providing enough details about efforts to comply with that order.
The Supreme Court largely upheld her order to “facilitate” the return of Abrego Garcia to the US, but caveated that she must show “due regard for the deference owed to the Executive Branch in the conduct of foreign affairs.”
Top brass of the Trump administration, such as White House Deputy Chief of Staff for Policy Stephen Miller, have argued that the Supreme Court’s ruling doesn’t require the administration to pressure El Salvador for Abrego Garcia’s return.
Instead, they contend that the high court merely wants the administration to “facilitate” the 29-year-old’s return if El Salvador releases him.
“Defendants—and their counsel—well know that the falsehood lies not in any supposed ‘premise,’ but in their continued mischaracterization of the Supreme Court’s Order,” Xinis chided Tuesday about the Trump administration’s characterizations of the high court’s ruling.
“That Order made clear that this Court ‘properly required the Government to “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s release from custody in El Salvador and to ensure that his case is handled as it would have been had he not been improperly sent to El Salvador.’”
Abrego Garcia had been among the 260 alleged gangbangers the Trump administration flew to El Salvador’s notoriously brutal Terrorism Confinement Center (CECOT) under war powers from the 1798 Alien Enemies Act.
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR MORNING REPORT NEWSLETTER
He has since been transferred to a lower security prison center in Santa Ana, El Salvador, according to Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), who visited him last week.
In a March 31 filing, the Trump administration said that Abrego Garcia’s removal was due to an “administrative error” and a “clerical error” because the October 2019 order was still in effect. However, officials such as Miller have since claimed that the attorneys made a mistake in saying that.
A citizen of El Salvador, Abrego Garcia had illegally entered the US in 2011, but a 2019 court order restricted him from being sent there due to concerns he could be targeted by the Barrio 18 criminal gang.
The Trump administration has accused him of affiliation with the ruthless MS-13 transnational gang, claiming he was confirmed as one by a “proven and reliable source.”
Officials have claimed that he was discovered having “rolls of cash and drugs” when he was detained and that he had been “arrested with two other members of MS-13.”
Abrego Garcia’s attorneys and family deny that he was a member of MS-13.
El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele has publicly poured cold water on the notion of sending Abrego Garcia back to the US, calling such questions “preposterous.”
For top headlines, breaking news and more, visit nypost.com.
Comments / 73
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
New York Post
RANGE
A 12-year-old killed herself at a Spokane hospital that recently closed its youth psychiatric unit
This story was originally published by InvestigateWest , a nonprofit newsroom dedicated to change-making investigative journalism. Sign up for their Watchdog Weekly newsletter to receive stories like this one in your inbox. Reach Whitney Bryen at 208-918-2458 or whitney@investigatewest.org. Reach Kaylee Tornay at 503-877-4108 or kaylee@investigatewest.org.
New York Post
Coward mom who beat daughter Julissia Batties, 7, to death refuses to come to court to learn punishment
The coward Bronx mom who admitted she beat her helpless 7-year-old daughter to death refused to show her face in court Tuesday — twisting the knife for the tragic girl’s kin who’s waited far too long for justice. Navasia Jones, 35, weaseled her way out of coming face to face with little Julissia Batties’ father and grandmother — who were set to deliver blistering victim impact statements in Bronx Supreme Court ahead of getting slapped with a 15-year sentence — by complaining that press was present in the courtroom. “She’s running away from what I have to say,” Julius Batties said. “She’s scared to face her daughter’s father after what she did. She needs to be dragged out and hear what we have to say. “This is her own little mind game of work in the system,” he added. Jullisia Batties, 7, was found battered in her family’s Bronx apartment in 2021 after being beaten to death by her mom. Obtained by the NY Post Navisia Jones was charged with murder three years after her 7-year-old daughter, Julissia Batties, was beaten to death. Robert Miller Southern California couple and their daughter charged with torture of 6 foster children Jones pleaded
New York Post
Golden Gate Media
New York Post
Herbie J Pilato
Former Child Star Bobby Buntrock Retired After 'Hazel' and Then Died Tragically at Only 21 Years Old
It's been over 50 years since the tragic demise of former child star Bobby Buntrock, best known as Harold Baxter on TV's beloved sitcom Hazel (NBC/CBS, 1961-1966). On April 7, 1974, Buntrock was in a fatal car accident on a bridge in Keystone, South Dakota. Like too many former child stars, before, during, and after his lifetime, Buntrock's life ended horrifically. This is his sad story.
New York Post
Herbie J Pilato
The Anti-Gay Anita Bryant Died Five Months Ago: A Look Back at Her Turbulent Life and Career
It's been five months since the demise of Anita Bryant, the former Miss Oklahoma, Grammy-nominated singer, orange juice lover, and outspoken opposer of gay rights. Bryant was 84 when she died of an undisclosed cause on December 16, 2024, at her home in Edmond, Oklahoma. This is her story.
Comments /